Celebrity Tattoo News: Kate Moss’s Partnership with Carphone Warehouse
Do you think of your mobile phone as a fashion accessory to complement your wardrobe? This Kat has only changed her iPhone case once – when she dropped her phone and broke the first case. But Kate Moss views mobile phones and tablets as fashion accessories and has thus teamed up with Carphone Warehouse to add her fashion flair to Carphone Warehouse’s newest range of accessories.
Interestingly, this report about the partnership notes that Ms Moss’s logo for her line of mobile accessories centres around an anchor tattoo that she sports on her wrist.
These prior lawsuits got this Kat wondering: Did Ms Moss and the tattoo artist who inked her wrist sign a "work for hire" agreement that transferred ownership of the copyright in the tattoo design to Ms Moss? If not, it seems like a risky proposition for Ms Moss and Carphone Warehouse to use the design as a trade mark for their jointly branded line of products. Given that the anchor tattoo has been highly visible in various ads featuring Kate Moss, as in the photo, right, it is likely that she gained ownership of the tattoo. On the other hand, if the creator of the tattoo did not transfer ownership of the tattoo, but merely approved of, or failed to object to, the tattoo's visibility in photographs of Ms Moss, even those photographs used commercially, Ms Moss should not rely on the prior uses when creating designs for Carphone Warehouse. The creator might consider the incorporation of the design into Ms Moss's Carphone Warehouse logo to be a violation of his or her copyright in the design.
Interestingly, this report about the partnership notes that Ms Moss’s logo for her line of mobile accessories centres around an anchor tattoo that she sports on her wrist. In the US, there have been several major lawsuits in which a tattoo artist has asserted copyright over the commercial use of the tattoo design by the recipient of the tattoo or a party affiliated with the recipient. The most notable of such lawsuits are those involving the artists who created tattoos for sportsmen MikeTyson and Rasheed Wallace. In Mike Tyson’s case, the artist who created the tattoo that covers half of Mr Tyson's face sued the producers of the movie The Hangover II for using a replica of his tattoo in the film and in advertisements for the film (reported on by the AmeriKat here). And Nike learned the hard way that celebrities don’t necessarily own the copyright in their body art. The tattoo artist who created Rasheed Wallace’s tattoo sued Nike for creating a commercial that specifically focused on the tattoo itself rather than Mr Wallace as a whole. While a tattoo artist who creates a work for a celebrity must understand (and probably desires) that the tattoo will be featured in photographs and videos of the celebrity (given that the tattoo becomes a part of the celebrity’s body), that understanding may not extend to all commercial uses.
These prior lawsuits got this Kat wondering: Did Ms Moss and the tattoo artist who inked her wrist sign a "work for hire" agreement that transferred ownership of the copyright in the tattoo design to Ms Moss? If not, it seems like a risky proposition for Ms Moss and Carphone Warehouse to use the design as a trade mark for their jointly branded line of products. Given that the anchor tattoo has been highly visible in various ads featuring Kate Moss, as in the photo, right, it is likely that she gained ownership of the tattoo. On the other hand, if the creator of the tattoo did not transfer ownership of the tattoo, but merely approved of, or failed to object to, the tattoo's visibility in photographs of Ms Moss, even those photographs used commercially, Ms Moss should not rely on the prior uses when creating designs for Carphone Warehouse. The creator might consider the incorporation of the design into Ms Moss's Carphone Warehouse logo to be a violation of his or her copyright in the design. Would any readers care to comment?
